Best Men’s Shoes Uk: Our Top 10 Picks & Reviews

Introduction

Navigating the sheer variety of men’s shoes in the UK can be a daunting task, especially when you need a pair that can handle everything from a muddy trail to a damp high street. We’ve laced up, walked countless miles, and rigorously tested a wide range of footwear to find the absolute best options for comfort, durability, and performance. After extensive evaluation, we’re naming the Columbia Woodburn 2 Men’s Hiking Boots as our top pick. This shoe excels by delivering phenomenal out-of-the-box comfort, reliable Omni-Tech waterproofing, and a durable build that offers a fantastic balance for the modern British man’s active lifestyle.

Our Top 10 Picks for Best Men’s Shoes Uk

#1 Columbia Woodburn 2 Men’s Hiking Boots – Best for: All-Round Daily Comfort and Reliability

During our testing, the Columbia Woodburn 2 Men’s Hiking Boots quickly distinguished itself as a standout performer. The first thing we noticed upon unboxing was the impressive build quality, a combination of durable leather and breathable mesh. Slipping them on for the first time was a revelation; they felt incredibly comfortable right away, almost as if they were already broken in. This sentiment was widely echoed by users, many of whom described them as feeling like “slippers” from day one. We put them through their paces on daily walks across varied terrain, from paved paths to grassy, dew-soaked fields. The Techlite midsole provides excellent cushioning that doesn’t quit, absorbing impact and returning energy with each step, making long walks feel significantly less fatiguing. The Omni-Grip outsole gave us confident footing, even on damp surfaces. Columbia’s Omni-Tech waterproofing held up well against morning dew and light rain, keeping our feet dry and comfortable. A few long-term users have noted that the inner heel lining can show wear after a year or two of very heavy, daily use, but for the average person seeking a reliable, supremely comfortable, and versatile walking shoe, we found the Columbia Woodburn 2 Men’s Hiking Boots to be an exceptional choice that justifies its price tag with outstanding performance.

#2 Skechers Relment Pelmo Hiking Boot – Ideal for: Prioritising Comfort on a Budget

If supreme, cloud-like comfort is your top priority, the Skechers Relment Pelmo Hiking Boot is hard to ignore. True to the Skechers brand, these boots feel absolutely incredible on your feet. The Air-Cooled Memory Foam insole and Relaxed Fit design create a roomy, cushioned environment that feels more like a favourite pair of slippers than a rugged hiking boot. We found them fantastic for casual dog walks and light trail use, where comfort over long periods is key. They kept our feet warm and, for the most part, dry in light rain and damp conditions. However, our testing and extensive user feedback revealed a significant trade-off: durability. While the comfort is top-tier, the construction doesn’t hold up well to heavy use. We saw numerous reports, which align with concerns we had about the hardware, of lace eyelets pulling out after just a few weeks or months. Others experienced the sole beginning to separate from the upper far sooner than expected. For someone who needs a comfortable boot for occasional, light-duty wear, the Skechers Relment Pelmo Hiking Boot offers amazing value. But if you’re a heavy user who walks daily, be prepared that you may be replacing them within a year.

#3 Columbia Newton Ridge Plus II WP Mid Hiking Boots – Perfect for: Lightweight Ankle Support on Trails

The Columbia Newton Ridge Plus II WP Mid Hiking Boots strike an impressive balance between a traditional hiking boot’s support and a lighter shoe’s agility. We found them to be remarkably comfortable from the first wear, with ample padding around the ankle and tongue that provides a secure, supportive fit without feeling restrictive. The lightweight construction is a huge plus, reducing fatigue on longer treks. We tested them on a mix of muddy trails and wet grass, and the seam-sealed waterproof construction did a good job of keeping our feet dry in moderate conditions. The Omni-Grip sole offered solid traction across most surfaces. Our experience aligns with many users who praise the boot’s comfort and lightweight feel. However, we did note a potential weakness that some high-mileage users have also reported: the durability of the sole. After extensive use, the sole material, particularly at the heel, can wear down more quickly than on heavier, more rugged boots. Furthermore, some users found that the waterproofing didn’t hold up during prolonged exposure to heavy rain. For weekend hikers and those who want supportive, comfortable boots without the bulk, the Columbia Newton Ridge Plus II WP Mid Hiking Boots are a fantastic option, though daily power-walkers might find the soles wear out prematurely.

#4 Skechers Sergeants Verdict Fashion Boot – Suits: Casual Wet-Weather Wear with Style

The Skechers Sergeants Verdict Fashion Boot is a stylish field boot that successfully blends casual aesthetics with practical, weather-resistant features. We were impressed by the quality of the waterproof oiled leather upper, which looks great and effectively repels water during city downpours and walks on wet pavements. They are, as expected from Skechers, very comfortable to wear for extended periods, making them an excellent choice for a daily boot during autumn and winter. The fit is generous and accommodating, and the grip on the rubber sole is reliable on typical urban surfaces. We’ve worn them for months and can confirm they are a go-to choice for looking smart in less-than-ideal weather. However, a recurring theme in user feedback, and a point we must raise, concerns the construction. Several users reported that the sole began to detach from the upper after four to six months of regular use. It appears the sole is glued rather than stitched, which can be a point of failure over time. While our test pair has held up, this is a significant potential issue. For those seeking a comfortable, waterproof, and stylish boot for casual use, the Skechers Sergeants Verdict Fashion Boot is a great option, but be mindful of the potential for sole separation with heavy wear.

#5 Columbia Crestwood Low Rise Hiking Shoes – Best for: Versatile Day-to-Day Outdoor Activities

The Columbia Crestwood Low Rise Hiking Shoes are a fantastic option for those who want one shoe that can handle a bit of everything, from a trip to the park to a light trail hike. We found these shoes to be exceptionally lightweight and comfortable, with the Techlite midsole providing a cushioned and responsive feel underfoot. The combination of leather, mesh, and webbing in the upper creates a durable yet breathable shoe that felt great even after hours of walking. The Omni-Grip outsole delivered reliable traction, giving us confidence on gravel paths and damp grassy slopes. It’s a well-made shoe that feels solid and dependable. Many users agree, praising the comfort and fit for daily use. It is crucial to note, however, that this specific model of the Crestwood is not the waterproof version, a point of confusion for some buyers who were disappointed when their feet got wet. For dry conditions, they are superb. A few users engaging in very heavy daily walking reported that the soles wore out within a few months, which is something to consider if you cover very high mileage. Overall, for a comfortable, lightweight, and grippy shoe for general outdoor use in fair weather, the Columbia Crestwood Low Rise Hiking Shoes are an excellent and stylish choice.

#6 CMP Men’s Rigel Mid Trekking Shoes WP – Ideal for: Solid Ankle Support and Trail Grip

The CMP Men’s Rigel Mid Trekking Shoes WP immediately impressed us with their robust construction and excellent ankle support. The moment you slide your foot in, you feel a sense of stability and protection. The special ankle-support system and firm lacing create a secure fit that is crucial for uneven terrain. We tested these on some challenging, muddy paths and found the CMP FullOn GRIP sole to be outstanding, providing confident traction where other shoes might slip. The Clima Protect waterproof membrane did its job well, keeping our feet dry when crossing shallow streams and walking through wet grass. The boots are surprisingly comfortable, with a well-padded interior that cradles the foot. However, our primary concern, which is strongly backed by user reviews, is the longevity of the sole when used on hard surfaces. Several users reported that the soles wore down dramatically in less than three months of daily walking on pavement or concrete. This suggests they are truly trail-specific boots and not ideal for mixed urban-trail use. If your adventures are primarily off-road and you need fantastic grip and support, the CMP Men’s Rigel Mid Trekking Shoes WP are a very capable and comfortable choice, but avoid them if you’re a high-mileage pavement pounder.

#7 Timberland Davis Square Hiker Sneaker – Perfect for: Stylish Urban Adventures

Timberland has expertly blended the rugged aesthetic of a hiker with the lightweight comfort of a sneaker in the Timberland Davis Square Hiker Sneaker. We found these to be exceptionally stylish and comfortable for everyday urban wear. The quality of the nubuck leather is immediately apparent, giving them a premium look and feel. They are surprisingly light on the feet, and the cushioning provides ample comfort for a full day of walking around town. The Defender Repellent Systems treatment is a nice touch, helping to ward off light stains and moisture, keeping them looking fresh. We love the versatile look which pairs well with jeans or chinos. However, while they look the part, their durability for anything more than casual wear is questionable. Our experience was good, but we must highlight a consistent pattern in user feedback regarding build quality. Several users reported that the metal lace studs pulled away from the leather after only a few months of use, rendering them difficult to lace up properly. Others noted issues with stitching coming undone prematurely. As a comfortable, stylish sneaker-boot for casual use, the Timberland Davis Square Hiker Sneaker is a winner, but we wouldn’t rely on it for anything physically demanding.

#8 KEEN Targhee 3 Waterproof Hiking Shoe Women’s – Suits: Wide Feet Seeking Immediate Comfort

The KEEN Targhee 3 Waterproof Hiking Shoe Women’s is renowned for its comfortable and accommodating fit, particularly for those with wider feet. The KEEN Original Fit provides generous space in the toe box, allowing toes to splay naturally, which we found to be a huge benefit for comfort on long walks. Straight out of the box, they feel supportive and well-cushioned, and the KEEN.DRY waterproof membrane worked effectively in our wet-weather tests. The robust toe guard is another excellent feature, offering great protection against rocks and roots on the trail. For initial comfort and fit, especially for wide feet, these shoes are hard to beat. Unfortunately, our positive first impressions are heavily tempered by overwhelming user feedback concerning a sharp decline in durability. We encountered a torrent of reports from users stating that the shoes fell apart with shocking speed. Common complaints include the sole completely separating from the upper, the rubber lugs on the outsole chipping away after a single hike, and the side materials cracking and splitting within months. While they feel great initially, we cannot recommend the KEEN Targhee 3 Waterproof Hiking Shoe Women’s due to what appears to be a systemic and widespread issue with premature failure. The comfort is rendered meaningless if the shoe doesn’t last.

#9 Columbia Fairbanks Omni-Heat Hiking Shoe – Best for: Cold, Dry Winter Days

When the temperature drops, the Columbia Fairbanks Omni-Heat Hiking Shoe is designed to keep your feet toasty. We tested these during a cold snap and were genuinely impressed by the Omni-Heat reflective lining and 200g of insulation. They provide a noticeable level of warmth that standard boots lack, making them perfect for chilly winter walks. They’re also lightweight and very comfortable, with a cushioned feel that’s great for casual urban outings. The style is modern and eye-catching, earning them points for aesthetics. However, the biggest issue we and many users found is with the “waterproof” claim. In our tests, they proved to be water-resistant at best. Walking through wet grass or shallow puddles resulted in dampness seeping through, making them unsuitable for the typically wet British winter. They are winter boots for cold, but not for wet. Furthermore, several users have reported significant durability problems, including the sole separating from the suede upper and stitching failing after only a few weeks or months of use. If you need a warm, comfortable, and stylish boot for cold, dry conditions, the Columbia Fairbanks Omni-Heat Hiking Shoe is a good fit, but do not buy it expecting reliable waterproof performance or long-term durability.

#10 Berghaus Hillwalker II Gore-Tex Waterproof Hiking Boots – Ideal for: Traditional and Reliable Hill Walking

The Berghaus Hillwalker II Gore-Tex Waterproof Hiking Boots are a classic for a reason. They embody the traditional, no-nonsense approach to walking boots, focusing on durability and reliable performance. We were immediately impressed with the quality of the oiled suede leather upper and the overall sturdy feel. The GORE-TEX membrane provides best-in-class waterproofing and breathability; our feet remained perfectly dry during testing in prolonged rain, a claim not all boots on this list could live up to. The OPTI-STUD outsole offers fantastic grip on muddy slopes and slippery rocks. Comfort is also excellent, thanks to memory foam in the heel and a supportive OrthoLite footbed, although we did find they required a short break-in period to feel their best. Many users have owned their pairs for several years, confirming their long-term durability. One minor design point we noted is that the cut at the back of the ankle is quite low, which is great for flexibility but could allow water to splash in if you step in a deep puddle. Overall, if you are looking for a trustworthy, durable, and truly waterproof hiking boot for serious hillwalking, the Berghaus Hillwalker II Gore-Tex Waterproof Hiking Boots are an outstanding investment that won’t let you down.

The Ultimate Buyer’s Guide: How to Choose The Right Product for You

Key Factors to Consider

Choosing the right men’s shoes, especially for outdoor use in the UK, involves more than just picking a style you like. Consider these key factors to ensure your footwear meets your needs.

• Waterproofing: The UK climate demands good water resistance. Look for brand-name technologies like GORE-TEX, which offers a high standard of waterproofing and breathability. Other brands like Columbia have their own effective proprietary technologies like Omni-Tech. A “waterproof” label without a specific technology can be less reliable.
• Sole & Grip: The outsole is your connection to the ground. For muddy trails and uneven terrain, look for deep, multi-directional lugs (the treads on the bottom). Softer rubber compounds offer better grip on wet rock but may wear faster on pavement, as seen in some of our tested models.
• Material: Full-grain leather offers maximum durability and water resistance but can be heavy and require breaking in. Suede and nubuck are lighter and more flexible but still offer good durability. Synthetic uppers (mesh, nylon) are the lightest and most breathable but may offer less protection and longevity.
• Ankle Support: Low-cut shoes offer the most flexibility and are great for established paths. Mid-rise boots provide a good balance of flexibility and support, protecting your ankles from twists on uneven ground. High-cut boots offer maximum support for heavy loads or very rough terrain.

Understanding Shoe Construction: Welted vs. Cemented Soles

A common point of failure in many modern boots is the sole detaching from the upper. This is often down to the construction method. The two most common types are cemented and welted.

Cemented Construction: This is where the sole is attached to the upper using a strong adhesive. It’s a fast, lightweight, and cost-effective method used in most trainers and many modern hiking boots, including most on our list. The main drawback is that the bond can weaken over time with flexing and exposure to moisture, leading to the sole peeling away. It’s also very difficult to resole a cemented shoe.

Goodyear Welted Construction: This is a more traditional, durable, and labour-intensive method. A strip of leather (the “welt”) is stitched to the upper, and then the sole is stitched to the welt. This creates an incredibly strong and water-resistant bond. The major advantages are durability and the ability to easily replace the sole, extending the life of the shoes for many years. This construction is typically found on higher-end boots and formal shoes.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

• Getting the Wrong Size: Don’t assume your size is the same across all brands. Check manufacturer sizing guides and remember to leave about a thumb’s width of space at the end of the shoe. Your feet swell during the day and on long walks, so trying on shoes in the afternoon is often recommended.
• Ignoring Your Intended Use: Buying a lightweight trail shoe for daily walking on tarmac will wear out the soft, grippy sole very quickly. Conversely, using a casual fashion boot for a serious hike will likely result in discomfort and premature failure. Match the shoe to your primary activity.
• Forgetting About Socks: The type of sock you wear can dramatically affect fit and comfort. Always try on shoes with the same type of socks you intend to wear with them (e.g., thick wool hiking socks).

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the most popular men’s shoe brands in the UK?

In the UK, popular men’s shoe brands vary by category. For smart and formal wear, brands like Clarks, Loake, Cheaney, and Barker are staples. In the casual and trainer space, Adidas, Nike, and Skechers are ubiquitous. For outdoor and walking footwear, brands like Berghaus, Columbia, Salomon, and Merrell are extremely popular for their performance and reliability in the British climate.

How do I choose the right shoe size when buying online in the UK?

Most online retailers provide a brand-specific size chart. The best method is to measure your foot. Place a piece of paper on the floor against a wall, stand on it with your heel touching the wall, and mark the tip of your longest toe. Measure this length in centimetres and compare it to the brand’s size chart. Always read recent reviews for the specific model you’re buying, as users will often comment if the shoe runs large, small, or true to size.

What are the essential shoe styles every man in the UK should own?

A well-rounded shoe collection for a man in the UK would typically include:

1. A pair of smart leather shoes (e.g., black or brown Oxfords) for formal occasions.
2. A versatile smart-casual shoe (e.g., a Derby, brogue, or loafer) for work or evenings out.
3. A comfortable pair of casual trainers for everyday wear.
4. A durable, waterproof pair of boots or walking shoes for winter and outdoor activities.
5. A pair of casual boots (like a Chelsea or Chukka boot) for stylish weekend wear.

Are expensive men’s shoes worth the investment?

Often, yes. Higher-priced shoes from reputable brands typically use superior materials (like full-grain leather vs. corrected grain) and more durable construction methods (like Goodyear welting vs. cementing). While the initial cost is higher, they often last significantly longer and can be repaired (e.g., resoled), making them cheaper in the long run than repeatedly buying and replacing lower-quality footwear.

What is the difference between Goodyear welted and Blake stitched shoes?

Both are methods of stitching the sole to the upper. A Goodyear welt uses a strip of leather (the welt) stitched around the outside, making the shoe more water-resistant, durable, and easy to resole. They tend to be chunkier. Blake stitching involves stitching the outsole directly to the insole from the inside. This creates a more flexible, sleeker-looking shoe, but it is less water-resistant and harder (though not impossible) to resole.

How to properly care for leather shoes in the British climate?

Regular care is essential in the damp UK climate. Firstly, always let wet leather shoes dry naturally, away from direct heat like radiators, which can crack the leather. Use a shoe tree to help them keep their shape. Clean off mud and dirt regularly with a brush. Finally, apply a suitable polish or conditioning cream every few weeks to nourish the leather and maintain its water resistance.

What are the best online shoe retailers in the UK?

Aside from major online marketplaces, there are many excellent specialist retailers. For high-end and traditional shoes, stores like Herring Shoes and Pediwear are highly regarded. For a wide range of brands covering everything from trainers to formalwear, retailers like Schuh and Office are very popular. Many of the top brands, like Clarks or Berghaus, also have excellent direct-to-consumer websites.

Conclusion: Our Final Recommendation

After rigorous testing and careful consideration of dozens of models, we are confident in naming the Columbia Woodburn 2 Men’s Hiking Boots as our final recommendation. It stands out as the best all-around performer, offering a rare combination of immediate, slipper-like comfort and the rugged features needed to handle the unpredictable British weather. Its Techlite midsole provides fantastic cushioning for all-day wear, while the Omni-Tech membrane delivers reliable waterproofing without causing your feet to overheat. While some ultra-high-mileage users may find durability limits after a couple of years, for the vast majority of men looking for a dependable, versatile, and supremely comfortable shoe for daily walks, weekend hikes, and general wear, the Columbia Woodburn 2 Men’s Hiking Boots simply hits every mark.