CMP Men’s Rigel MID Trekking Shoes WP Review: A Deep Dive into Comfort, Grip, and Longevity

There’s a specific kind of frustration every avid walker knows. It’s the feeling of staring at a collection of footwear, none of which seems quite right for the day’s plan. You have the heavy-duty mountaineering boots, overkill for a stroll through the local woods. You have the comfortable trainers, which promise a soggy disaster the moment you step on dewy grass. What’s missing is the versatile workhorse: a boot that offers the rugged support and waterproofing for a muddy trail, yet feels light and comfortable enough for an impromptu pub lunch afterwards. I’ve spent years searching for this elusive sweet spot, a boot that bridges the gap between extreme performance and everyday usability without demanding a premium price tag. The challenge is finding a pair that delivers on its promises of comfort, grip, and weather protection, not just for the first few outings, but for the long haul. This search is what led me to the CMP Men’s Rigel MID Trekking Shoes WP, a boot that aims to be that perfect, affordable all-rounder.

What to Demand from Your Next Pair of Trekking Shoes

A pair of men’s walking boots is more than just footwear; it’s a key solution for comfort, safety, and enjoyment in the great outdoors. The primary problem they solve is protecting your feet from the elements and the terrain. A quality boot keeps you dry during unexpected downpours, provides stability on treacherous, uneven surfaces, and cushions your joints from the repetitive impact of a long hike. The main benefits are clear: reduced risk of slips and falls, prevention of painful blisters, and the ability to explore further and for longer, confident that your feet are well-supported and protected. Without them, a beautiful day out can quickly turn into a miserable, painful ordeal.

The ideal customer for this type of product is the enthusiastic day-hiker, the weekend adventurer, the dog walker who traverses muddy fields, or anyone who needs reliable, waterproof footwear for varied conditions. They value a blend of performance and value. However, a mid-weight trekking shoe like this might not be suitable for those tackling serious alpine ascents or multi-day expeditions in extreme weather, who would require a more specialized, rigid mountaineering boot. Similarly, trail runners or those who prioritize speed and minimal weight above all else might find them a bit cumbersome and would be better served by a dedicated trail running shoe.

Before investing, consider these crucial points in detail:

• Fit & Sizing: This is the single most important factor. A boot that is too tight will cause blisters and black toenails on descents, while a boot that is too loose will allow your foot to slide, causing friction and instability. Always try boots on with the type of socks you intend to wear, preferably at the end of the day when your feet are slightly swollen. Many users recommend going up a half or full size in hiking boots to ensure ample room in the toe box.
• Waterproofing & Breathability: A waterproof membrane is essential for UK walking. Technologies like CMP’s own Clima Protect aim to block external moisture while allowing sweat vapor to escape, keeping your feet dry from both the inside and out. The effectiveness of this balance is what separates a good boot from a great one, as a non-breathable boot can leave your feet just as damp from sweat as a non-waterproof one would from rain.
• Materials & Durability: The upper material dictates the boot’s ruggedness, breathability, and weight. The CMP Men’s Rigel MID Trekking Shoes WP uses 100% suede leather, which offers excellent durability and conformity to the foot over time, combined with synthetic panels for flexibility. The sole unit, comprising the outsole (rubber for grip), midsole (EVA for cushioning), and insole (Ortholite for comfort), is where long-term durability is truly tested.
• Ankle Support & Sole Stiffness: A mid-cut design, like this model, provides crucial ankle support to prevent twists and sprains on uneven terrain. The sole’s stiffness is a trade-off: a very stiff sole is great for mountaineering and edging on rock, but can feel clumsy and fatiguing on flatter paths. A boot like the Rigel aims for a happy medium, offering enough flexibility for comfortable walking with enough rigidity to protect your foot from sharp rocks underfoot.

While the CMP Men’s Rigel MID Trekking Shoes WP is an excellent choice, it’s always wise to see how it stacks up against the competition. For a broader look at all the top models, we highly recommend checking out our complete, in-depth guide:

Unboxing the Rigel: First Impressions and Key Features

Pulling the CMP Men’s Rigel MID Trekking Shoes WP from the box, the first thing we noticed was its striking, sporty aesthetic. The black suede leather is punctuated by contrast-colour details, giving it a modern look that doesn’t scream “old-fashioned hiker.” They feel substantial and robust in the hand without being excessively heavy; at around 520 grams for a mid-size boot, they strike a good balance between protection and weight. The build quality feels solid for its price point. The stitching is neat, the protective rand around the toe and heel is reassuringly tough, and the lacing system, which extends far down the foot, suggests a highly customisable fit. Slipping them on for the first time was a pleasant surprise. Many boots in this category can feel stiff and unforgiving initially, requiring a lengthy break-in period. These, however, felt remarkably comfortable from the get-go, a sentiment echoed by many users who praise their out-of-the-box wearability. The padding around the ankle collar and tongue is generous, and the Ortholite insole provides a welcome softness underfoot. You can see its full feature set and user reviews to get a sense of this initial positive reaction.

Putting the CMP Rigel to the Test: A Performance Breakdown

A boot’s true character is only revealed on the trail. A spec sheet can tell you about membranes and materials, but it can’t describe the feeling of secure footing on a slippery descent or the simple joy of finishing a long walk with dry, comfortable feet. We took the CMP Men’s Rigel MID Trekking Shoes WP through its paces over several weeks, subjecting it to a mix of environments: sodden forest paths, rocky coastal scrambles, and long walks on hard-packed trails, to see how its key features hold up in the real world.

Comfort Straight from the Box: The Ortholite and EVA Combination

The most immediate and impressive quality of the CMP Men’s Rigel MID Trekking Shoes WP is its comfort. Often, new boots come with a dreaded “break-in” period, a painful purgatory of rubbing and blisters before the leather conforms to your foot. We experienced none of that here. From the very first mile, the boot felt accommodating and supportive. The secret lies in its well-designed internal structure. The Ortholite insole provides a fantastic first layer of cushioning; it’s breathable, helps manage moisture, and retains its shape well over time. Beneath that, the EVA midsole does the heavy lifting of shock absorption. On hard, unforgiving surfaces, this combination worked wonders, taking the sting out of every footfall and reducing fatigue in our legs and joints over a long day. We found the fit to be snug and secure, thanks largely to the lacing system which allows for precise tightening across the entire foot.

This experience is strongly corroborated by user feedback. One wearer noted they were “comodísimas” (extremely comfortable) from the first moment, while another was “pleased with every aspect of the boots very comfortable.” However, sizing is a point of debate. We found our usual size to be a good fit with a standard hiking sock, but some users advise sizing up by a half or full number, especially to prevent toes from hitting the front on steep descents. One reviewer mentioned that a recent model seemed shorter than an older one of the same size, suggesting manufacturing tolerances may vary. Our advice is to measure your feet carefully and consider going up half a size if you are between sizes or prefer wearing very thick socks. While we didn’t experience it, a couple of users mentioned the heel area can feel a bit hard initially, so pairing them with quality socks is a wise move. For anyone prioritizing immediate comfort, you can explore the full specifications of this comfortable boot.

Grip and Stability: Taming the Trail with FullOn GRIP

Comfort means little if you’re constantly worried about your footing. This is where the sole unit and ankle support of the Rigel truly shine. The outsole uses CMP’s proprietary FullOn GRIP rubber compound, moulded into a deep, aggressive lug pattern. We tested this extensively on slick, leaf-covered mud, wet limestone, and loose gravel—all conditions that can easily wrong-foot you. The grip was consistently excellent. The multi-directional lugs bite into soft ground with confidence, and the rubber compound felt surprisingly tacky on wet rock. One user highlighted this specifically, noting that “The directions of the lugs on the sole give you good grip regardless of the slope of the terrain you walk on.” We wholeheartedly agree.

This tenacious grip is complemented by a fantastic support structure. The “MID” in the name refers to its mid-height cut, which wraps securely around the ankle. This, combined with the dedicated ankle-support system and a rigid TPU heel seat, provides a powerful sense of stability. On rocky, uneven paths where a misplaced foot could lead to a twisted ankle, the boot kept our feet locked in and protected. It inspires confidence, allowing you to focus on the trail ahead rather than worrying about every step. The protective board integrated into the boot’s structure also does a great job of shielding the sole of your foot from sharp stones and roots. For hikers who frequent varied and challenging terrain, this level of grip and stability at this price is a major selling point.

The Waterproofing Question: How Dry is the Clima Protect Membrane?

Here we arrive at the most contentious feature of the CMP Men’s Rigel MID Trekking Shoes WP. The boot is equipped with a Clima Protect membrane, a thermal laminate designed to be both waterproof and breathable. The user feedback on its effectiveness is sharply divided, and our testing helped us understand why. During our trials, we walked through long, wet grass, crossed shallow streams, and were caught in several moderate rain showers. In these conditions, the boots performed admirably. Our feet remained completely dry and, importantly, didn’t feel clammy, suggesting the breathability is effective. The gusseted tongue, which is attached to the boot’s upper along the sides, successfully prevents water from seeping in around the laces.

However, we must acknowledge the significant number of users who have had a different experience. One disappointed walker reported that despite the “WATERPROOF” label, their boots let in water during a walk in light rain on a simple dirt track. Another stated that after ten months of use, their waterproof performance was “so far away” from what was advertised. Our conclusion is that the Clima Protect membrane is effective up to a point. It seems perfectly capable of handling morning dew, puddles, and typical British showers. But it may not withstand prolonged, torrential downpours or full submersion in the same way a premium Gore-Tex membrane would. For the majority of casual hiking, it’s more than adequate. But for those who venture out in the absolute worst weather, managing expectations is key.

Durability Under Scrutiny: The Elephant in the Room

This brings us to the boot’s biggest potential weakness: long-term durability, specifically of the sole. In our multi-week test, encompassing roughly 50-60 miles of varied terrain, the boots held up perfectly. The suede upper showed no signs of premature wear, the stitching remained intact, and the sole looked almost new. We were, frankly, impressed. But an expert review must look beyond short-term performance and consider the wealth of user experience available. And here, a clear and concerning pattern emerges.

Several users report catastrophic failures of the sole unit. One of the most damning reviews states that the soles and heels were “worn down through the rubber” in less than three months of use, primarily walking on concrete and tarmac. Another user, after a year and about five mountain tours, experienced the entire sole detaching from the upper. These are not isolated incidents. The common thread appears to be the type of surface. The FullOn GRIP compound, which provides such excellent traction on natural surfaces, seems to be too soft to withstand the constant abrasion of pavement. This explains the paradox: for a dedicated trail hiker, the boots might last well, but for someone using them as a daily driver for work or commuting, they could wear out alarmingly fast. It is a critical trade-off. The CMP Men’s Rigel MID Trekking Shoes WP offers incredible performance for its price, but that value diminishes if they need replacing every few months. This is a boot for the trails, not the tarmac. You can check the latest price and availability, keeping this important caveat in mind.

What Other Users Are Saying

Synthesizing the broad spectrum of customer feedback provides a remarkably clear picture of the CMP Men’s Rigel MID Trekking Shoes WP. On one side, there is effusive praise for the immediate comfort and performance. One user from Spain, after a hike in snow and sodden ground, was thrilled: “They performed very, very well, my feet were dry and warm… For the price they have, they are phenomenal, better than some with a [bigger] brand name.” This sentiment, celebrating the incredible value proposition, is a recurring theme.

On the other side, the criticism is laser-focused on two key areas. The most severe is durability, as summed up by a user who was blunt: “Purchased 11th September 2024 and soles and heels… worn down through the rubber by 1st December 2024! DIDN’T EVEN LAST 3 MONTHS! Waste of money!” This highlights the issue with using them on hard surfaces. The second point of contention is the waterproofing. While many, like the Spanish hiker, had great success, an Italian user had the opposite experience: “I went for a very quiet 10km walk… It started to rain lightly… and the boots, despite being advertised as ‘waterproof’, started to get my socks wet.” This split in opinion suggests a level of inconsistency in the performance of the Clima Protect membrane.

How Does the CMP Rigel Compare to the Competition?

No product exists in a vacuum. The CMP Men’s Rigel MID Trekking Shoes WP competes in a crowded marketplace, and understanding its alternatives is key to making an informed decision. While it excels in value and initial comfort, other boots may be better suited for different priorities.

1. Columbia Men’s Waterproof Hiking Boots

The Columbia Transverse represents a step up in brand recognition and, often, in consistent technological performance. Columbia’s Omni-Tech waterproof membrane is generally regarded as a reliable and well-tested system. For a hiker who frequently encounters wet weather and wants greater peace of mind regarding waterproofing, the Columbia boot is a very strong contender. It typically offers a similar mid-cut design with good cushioning and support. The trade-off is often a slightly higher price point. If your budget can stretch a bit further and you prioritize proven, consistent weather protection from a globally recognized outdoor brand over the raw value of the CMP, this is the alternative for you.

2. adidas Eastrail 2.0 Hiking Shoes

The adidas Eastrail 2.0 occupies a different niche, leaning more towards a “hiker-trainer” hybrid. This is a low-cut shoe, meaning it forgoes the ankle support of the CMP Rigel in favour of greater flexibility and lower weight. It’s an ideal choice for walkers who stick to well-maintained paths, forest tracks, and low-level trails where ankle-twisting hazards are minimal. Its design is perfect for fast-paced walks and for those who want a single piece of footwear that feels at home on the trail and in the city. However, for more rugged, uneven, or muddy terrain, the superior ankle support and more aggressive grip of the CMP Men’s Rigel MID Trekking Shoes WP would be the safer and more capable option.

3. FitVille Extra Wide Fit Walking Shoes

FitVille’s offering directly addresses a common complaint with many European boot brands: a narrow fit. As one review for the CMP Rigel noted, they can be “relatively narrow.” The FitVille walking shoe is specifically engineered for those with extra wide feet, prioritizing a comfortable, non-restrictive fit above all else. If you have struggled in the past with standard-width boots causing pinching or pressure points, this should be at the top of your list. While it may not have the same rugged, mountain-ready aesthetic as the Rigel, its focus on ergonomic comfort for a specific foot shape makes it a superior choice for wide-footed walkers seeking all-day comfort for less technical hiking and general outdoor use.

The Final Verdict: Is the CMP Men’s Rigel MID Trekking Shoes WP Right for You?

After extensive testing and analysis, our verdict on the CMP Men’s Rigel MID Trekking Shoes WP is one of qualified, enthusiastic recommendation. This is a boot that offers a phenomenal amount of performance for its price tag. The out-of-the-box comfort is exceptional, the grip is tenacious and confidence-inspiring on natural terrain, and the ankle support is robust. For the weekend warrior, the casual hiker, or the dog walker who sticks primarily to trails, fields, and forests, it represents one of the best value propositions on the market.

However, that value comes with two significant caveats. The inconsistent waterproofing means it might let you down in a true deluge, and the soft sole compound makes it a poor choice for anyone who plans to wear it regularly on pavement or other hard, abrasive surfaces. If you understand these limitations and your intended use aligns with its strengths, you will be rewarded with a comfortable, capable, and stylish hiking boot. It is a fantastic trail-focused boot that punches well above its weight. If you’re ready to hit the trails with a boot that offers immediate comfort and superb grip, you can find the best price for the CMP Rigel MID Trekking Shoes WP right here.